Fiddlehead - Baby I'll Change Review

 Return to Music Reviews 2026

Fiddlehead Baby I'll Change EP album cover featuring the band's latest emotionally driven alternative rock and post-hardcore release.

Enjoying the review? Use code BLOG10 for 10% off our apparel.

Don't change baby, you are perfect the way you are.

Since emerging in 2014 following the dissolution of the legendary Boston hardcore band Have Heart, Fiddlehead have steadily become one of the most emotionally compelling bands in modern alternative music. Fronted by Patrick Flynn alongside guitarist Alex Henery, guitarist Alex Dow, bassist Casey Nealon, and drummer Shawn Costa, the group has never relied on sheer aggression alone. Instead, they've built their identity around heartfelt songwriting, introspective lyricism, and a seamless blend of post-hardcore, emo, indie rock, and alternative rock.

Across Springtime and Blind, Between the Richness, and Death Is Nothing To Us, Fiddlehead explored themes of grief, family, healing, and perseverance with remarkable sincerity. Baby I'll Change continues that emotional journey, but rather than leaning heavily into the hardcore roots that defined their earlier work, the band embraces a brighter, more melodic direction. The result is an EP that feels warm, reflective, and deeply human without sacrificing the emotional honesty that has always made Fiddlehead so special.

The EP opens with "The Dogs," immediately showcasing the band's refined songwriting. Large, punchy drums establish the foundation while shimmering alternative rock guitars create an uplifting atmosphere. Beneath everything sits one of the record's strongest elements: an incredibly thick, warm bass tone that quietly anchors every melody. Patrick Flynn delivers one of his most restrained vocal performances to date, allowing emotion to come through naturally instead of overwhelming the listener with intensity.

As the song progresses, acoustic guitars quietly emerge underneath the larger arrangement, gradually building tension before layered backing vocals lift the chorus into something surprisingly hopeful. The production deserves enormous praise here, allowing every instrument enough space to breathe while maintaining a rich, full sound that never feels overproduced.

"Porchlight" continues the EP's melodic momentum with perhaps its catchiest chorus. Gentle drum grooves, clean guitar melodies, and beautifully balanced vocal harmonies create an inviting atmosphere that feels almost effortless. Once again, the bass becomes one of the stars of the song, sitting low in the mix with a warm, rounded tone that gives every section additional emotional depth.

Flynn's vocal performance perfectly complements the softer instrumentation. Rather than pushing into his familiar hardcore delivery, he leans into vulnerable melodies that feel remarkably sincere. The layered production gives the chorus a soaring quality without sacrificing intimacy, making it one of the EP's most immediately memorable moments.

The emotional centerpiece arrives with the title track, "Baby I'll Change." Opening with delicate guitar strums and understated vocals, the song patiently unfolds into the EP's most powerful performance. Flynn sounds genuinely vulnerable throughout, often allowing his voice to crack and strain naturally rather than smoothing over those imperfections. Those imperfections become the song's greatest strength.

The rhythm section deserves particular recognition. The bass slowly emerges beneath the acoustic foundation while the drums build patiently, using restrained cymbal work and subtle snare accents to increase tension without rushing toward the payoff. When the full band finally erupts into heavier guitars and more dynamic drumming, the release feels completely earned.

One especially memorable moment arrives when Flynn's isolated vocals briefly stand alone before the entire band crashes back into the mix. It's a simple production choice, but one that magnifies the emotional impact dramatically and serves as one of the strongest moments on the EP.

What makes Baby I'll Change so successful is its restraint. Fiddlehead understand that emotional weight doesn't always require explosive breakdowns or constant intensity. Instead, they allow atmosphere, melody, and thoughtful pacing to carry much of the record's emotional impact.

The production throughout the EP is exceptional. Every instrument occupies its own space without sounding overly polished. The bass remains consistently warm and prominent, the guitars alternate between shimmering indie textures and fuller alternative rock tones, and Shawn Costa's drumming provides just enough energy to push each song forward without dominating the arrangements.

Patrick Flynn continues proving that he's one of alternative music's most emotionally authentic vocalists. Whether delivering quiet reflections or more passionate climaxes, every lyric feels believable because nothing ever sounds forced or overly theatrical.

If there's one criticism, it's simply that the EP ends far too quickly. At only three songs, Baby I'll Change leaves listeners wanting considerably more. While each track feels complete individually, it's difficult not to imagine how effective this sonic direction could become across a full-length album.

Still, that's hardly a significant complaint. Rather than overstaying its welcome, the EP accomplishes exactly what it sets out to do: provide a concise snapshot of a band confidently exploring new territory while remaining true to its emotional core.

Baby I'll Change may be one of Fiddlehead's gentlest releases, but it's also one of their most affecting. Rich production, gorgeous bass work, memorable melodies, and Patrick Flynn's deeply human vocal performance combine into a beautiful collection of songs that continue expanding the band's already impressive legacy. It's a brief release, but one that lingers long after its final notes fade away.

NOTABLE TRACKS: 

The Dogs

Baby I'll Change

Instagram review

Return to Music Reviews

Return to  Music Review 2026

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.